A non-resident landlord in Qatar filed four self-assessment returns. The errors were not exotic. He treated himself as entitled to the UK personal allowance, then, on the 2023–24 return, typed £12,570 into two Double Taxation Agreement boxes that have nothing to do with the allowance. The return generated a refund of £25,140. HMRC held the money and opened an enquiry. The First-tier Tribunal has now dismissed the penalty appeal in Al Marri v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1450 (TC).
The cash that never left HMRC still counted. Potential lost revenue under Schedule 24 to the Finance Act 2007 includes an amount that would have been repayable had the inaccuracy not been corrected. The 2023–24 penalty alone was £4,017.39, being 15% of £26,782.60. Four years together came to £4,217.61. The appeal was dismissed on 20 October 2026.
If you sign group returns, or you have founders and directors who file their own, this is the file to lock before the next enquiry letter.
What the returns actually did
Mr Al Marri was not UK resident. He received UK rental income under the non-resident landlord scheme and had to file self-assessment. He did not dispute the inaccuracies. He said he had not been careless.
For 2020–21 and 2021–22 he failed to say he was non-resident and did not complete the SA109. The returns applied the personal allowance (£12,500, then £12,570) to UK income of £1,074 and £3,223. Tax that should have been £214.80 and £644.60 was shown as nil.
For 2022–23 he did tick non-residence, then put an X in box 15 of the SA109. That box is a claim to the personal allowance under a double tax agreement. The SA109 notes list the countries that work. Qatar is not on the list. Income of £2,377 produced no tax. The correct figure was £475.40. The UK–Qatar treaty is published by HMRC as the Qatar tax treaties collection. Treaty residence is not a personal allowance.
For 2023–24 he repeated the box 15 error on income of £8,213, which should have produced tax of £1,642.60. He also entered £12,570 in box 21 and again in box 22. Those boxes, read with Helpsheet 302, are claims for relief from UK tax already suffered, or for a repayment of tax deducted at source, where a treaty awards residence elsewhere. He had suffered no such tax. The return asked HMRC to repay £25,140. HMRC stopped the payment and wrote on 14 May 2025.
Careless is a standard, not a story
Paragraph 3 of Schedule 24 says an inaccuracy is careless if it is due to a failure to take reasonable care. The Tribunal applied the test in Collis v HMRC [2011] UKFTT 588 (TC): the prudent and reasonable taxpayer in that person’s position.
The appellant’s case was familiar. English was not his first language. He used translation tools. He had no tax training. The form is not intuitive. Treaty personal-allowance rules are complex. He said he had taken guidance from the financial team at Savills, the estate agent, and later engaged an accountant.
None of that moved the Tribunal.
On residence, a person who has already applied under the non-resident landlord scheme knows he is not UK resident. A prudent taxpayer either understands the return or gets someone who does. On box 15, the notes were clear and Qatar was absent. Putting an X in the box was a positive claim, not a blank left by confusion. Advice from an estate agent, even a financial team, is not a substitute for the notes or for a tax adviser. The notice of appeal itself said a professional accountant was engaged only afterwards.
Boxes 21 and 22 are harder. The Tribunal accepted that the guidance and the HS302 claim form are more complex than box 15. Reasonable care still required reading them before typing the personal-allowance figure into a repayment box. He accepted he had not done that. Had he read them, he would have seen they are not an allowance claim at all.
Language, lack of training, and a conversation with the agent do not lower the statutory standard to “I tried”.
The penalty is on the refund that was blocked
All four penalties were set at 15% of potential lost revenue. That is the floor for a careless inaccuracy with prompted disclosure. Unprompted disclosure can go lower. Prompted means the person had reason to believe HMRC had discovered, or were about to discover, the inaccuracy. Here disclosure came after the 14 May 2025 enquiry letter. The floor was correct.
The arithmetic:
- 2020–21: potential lost revenue £214.80, penalty £32.22
- 2021–22: £644.60, penalty £96.69
- 2022–23: £475.40, penalty £71.31
- 2023–24: £26,782.60, penalty £4,017.39
The 2023–24 figure is the £1,642.60 of tax that should have been paid, plus the £25,140 refund that paragraph 5(2) treats as potential lost revenue because it would have been repayable had the return not been corrected. HMRC never paid it. That does not shrink the penalty base. A discovery assessment or closure notice for the tax actually due is a separate debt. The penalty rides on the larger statutory concept.
The appellant said the penalties were disproportionate, that they exceeded £5,000, and that the error created no real loss and no burden. The Tribunal corrected the total: £4,217.61, not over £5,000. It also refused the “no loss” point. The statute already prices culpability. Deliberate behaviour starts at 70% before disclosure. Careless behaviour, fully reduced for prompted disclosure, sits at 15%. Special reduction and suspension are further, separate discretions. Using the statutory floor is not disproportionate merely because the repayment never cleared.
Suspension is a discretion, not a reward for hiring an accountant
Paragraph 14 of Schedule 24 lets HMRC suspend a careless-inaccuracy penalty only where a condition of suspension would help the person avoid further careless penalties. The Tribunal can interfere with a refusal only if the decision is flawed in a judicial-review sense. The burden is on the appellant.
HMRC’s factsheet CC/FS10 describes when a penalty can be suspended. Conditions have to be specific, measurable, achievable, realistic and time-bound. The factsheet does not say HMRC will suspend whenever a tidy condition can be written. Officer Dixon’s reasons, which the Tribunal accepted as rational, were blunt. Suspension is not a promise not to repeat the same mistake. Once HMRC has explained the error, a repeat looks deliberate, not careless. There was no system failure to fix. The returns were thin. “I have now hired an accountant” does not force a suspension.
That is the point finance teams miss when they treat a penalty schedule as a negotiation about contrition. Contrition is already priced into the disclosure reduction. Suspension needs a future inaccuracy you can actually condition against.
What to lock
Treat this as a controls note, not a morality tale about one landlord.
Residence and allowance boxes are claims. On any SA109, box 15 is a treaty personal-allowance claim. It is not a way of recording non-residence. Non-residence is a different question. The country list in the notes is the control. If the country is absent, the X is an inaccuracy, and a positive one.
Repayment boxes are not the allowance. Boxes 21 and 22, and HS302, deal with tax already charged or deducted. Entering the personal-allowance number there manufactures a refund. Potential lost revenue follows the refund the form asks for, whether or not HMRC pays it. Build a review that rejects a DTA repayment where the source papers show no UK tax deducted.
Agent comfort is not reasonable care. A managing agent, a payroll bureau, or a translation tool does not meet the Collis standard where the published notes answer the question. The engagement file needs a named adviser, the question asked, and the answer relied on, before the return is filed. “We asked the agent” failed here.
Prompted is the default once the letter arrives. Quality of disclosure still matters, but the unprompted floor is gone the moment HMRC writes. Do not wait for the meeting to “explain the position” if the inaccuracy is already visible. Tell, help, and give access, and record the dates.
Suspension needs a system, not a promise. If the error is a one-off misread of a box, expect the penalty to stand. If the error is a process (treaty residence checklist, NRL withholding, SA109 review), write the SMART condition yourself and put it in the reply. HMRC may still refuse. A reasoned refusal is hard to overturn.
Absence from the hearing does not pause the penalty. The Tribunal sat without the appellant under rule 33. He had been notified. Qatar is not a country from which the Tribunal will simply take oral evidence by video; the practice on oral evidence from abroad requires permission that was never sought. If a director is abroad, the evidence plan is part of the appeal, not an afterthought on the morning of the hearing.
The sums here are small beside a corporate enquiry. The structure is not. A blocked repayment is still potential lost revenue. A clear note on GOV.UK still defines reasonable care. And hiring the accountant after the enquiry does not rewind either of those facts.
This note is commentary on a published First-tier Tribunal decision. It is not advice on any person’s return.
