The First-tier Tribunal has dismissed a £569,175 input-tax appeal in Its Plant-Tech Limited v HMRC ([2026] UKFTT 1299 (TC)). The company outsourced payroll, took invoices that wrapped wages and employer’s NIC inside a VAT charge, and claimed the lot as deductible input tax. HMRC allowed recovery only on the processing fee. The Tribunal agreed: there was no taxable supply of staff or labour. The workers remained Its Plant-Tech’s employees. Wages and employer’s NIC were its own employment costs, not consideration for a supply under section 24 of VATA 1994.
That is a board-level VAT characterisation ruling, not a niche payroll footnote. If you run engineering groups, field-service businesses, PE portfolio companies with outsourced payroll, umbrella/PEO-adjacent structures, or any shared-service model that invoices “gross wages + NIC + fee + VAT”, Plant-Tech is this week’s file.
Primary sources: the FTT decision, Claritax’s case note, VATupdate’s summary, Academy of Tax Law’s analysis, and the Supreme Court test in Secret Hotels2.
What actually happened
Its Plant-Tech (ITS P-T) provides inspection, testing, training and maintenance in the wind-technology sector. Before 2019 it ran payroll in-house. After the payroll employee left, directors outsourced — first to MP Screeding Ltd, later to ITS Payroll Ltd. No written services contract with either provider was in evidence.
The payroll companies issued VAT invoices covering gross wages, employer’s NIC, a processing fee (1.5% of gross wages plus employer’s NIC), and VAT on the full amount. ITS P-T paid net wages and training costs from its own bank account. Those net amounts appeared as credits on the invoices, so only the balance was remitted. Input tax was claimed on the full VAT shown.
On 19 July 2023 HMRC assessed under section 73 VATA 1994. After review the denied input tax stood at £32,226 (period 06/19) and £536,949 (periods 09/19 to 03/22) — £569,175 total. Recovery on the fee was allowed. Everything else failed. The sole issue: labour supply, or payroll administration only?
The legal spine CFOs must keep straight
1. Input tax follows a taxable supply to you — not an invoice with a VAT line. Section 24 VATA defines input tax by reference to VAT on a supply to the taxpayer. If wages and employer’s NIC are not consideration for a supply made to you, VAT on those lines is not your input tax. The Tribunal applied Secret Hotels2: start with the contractual relationship, then test economic reality. With almost no contract, reality filled the gap — and pointed at payroll administration, not labour supply.
2. Payslips and a third-party PAYE scheme do not manufacture a change of employer. ITS Payroll payslips and a third-party PAYE reference proved processing at most. They did not prove employment contracts transferred, employer obligations moved, or labour was supplied back. The only employment contracts in evidence named ITS P-T. There was no novation evidence either way.
3. “TUPE” as commercial shorthand is worthless without a transfer of undertaking. Directors called the arrangements “TUPE”. The hearing accepted there was no transfer of an undertaking and no TUPE framework. Informal language does not move employment. Without employee consent to new contracts — and without documents — the transfer story collapses.
How the Tribunal read the facts
Judge Fairpo and Member Corrigan preferred contemporaneous evidence over later reconstruction:
- ITS P-T selected workers, refused unsuitable candidates, and kept day-to-day control
- it directed sites and tasks, and funded specialist training
- workers still went to ITS P-T with problems; Peninsula stayed on for employment-law support
- day-to-day reality showed “minimal disruption” after outsourcing
- annual accounts continued to show employees
- no written labour-supply agreement; invoices separately itemised a processing fee
- net wages left ITS P-T’s own bank account
If nothing material changes for the workforce except who prints the payslip, you have not bought staff. You have bought payroll processing. A withdrawn HMRC output-tax assessment against ITS Payroll on the same invoices was not a characterisation ITS P-T could bank. Sincere belief that employment transferred did not substitute for contracts, novations and consents.
Why this hits CFOs harder than payroll clerks
Cash and margin. £569k of denied input tax is pure leakage — real cash when assessments land years later with interest.
False comfort from a VAT line. Boards still treat a VAT-bearing invoice as self-proving. Itemising a fee can cut against you: it advertises that the rest is pass-through employment cost.
Employment residual stays with you. If you never transferred employment, you still carry dismissal, holiday pay, NMW, control facts, auto-enrolment and H&S — while claiming a VAT profile that assumes someone else is the employer. Diligence teams and HMRC now map that inconsistency.
Real staff-supply still works. Nothing here kills genuine agency models or documented secondments. What it kills is the hybrid: keep control, keep contracts, pay net wages yourself, and reclaim VAT as if you hired a staff-supply business. See also our notes on Tapi Carpets and Bolt principal status — different sectors, same rule: contracts and cash flows beat labels.
The CFO lock-list
- Employer map. Who is the legal employer on the worker’s contract? Who dismisses? Who runs grievances? Attach the contracts.
- Supply memo. One page: payroll admin only, staff/labour, or mixed? State consideration for each limb. Pass-through wages/NIC = no VAT reclaim.
- Invoice architecture. Separate fee from reimbursed employment costs. Do not accept VAT on wage/NIC pass-through without counsel sign-off on genuine labour supply.
- Payment flows. Paying net wages from your account is employer behaviour. Match the flow to a true labour supply, or stop the labour-supply reclaim.
- TUPE file. Demand transfer-of-undertaking analysis, ELI and consent trail. No papers, no transfer narrative.
- Accounts consistency. Headcount and staff costs must match the VAT story.
- Historic scan. Pull 4–6 years of returns. Quantify wage/NIC VAT reclaims. Amend under Notice 700/45 if needed.
- Diligence question. Does any group company reclaim VAT on outsourced payroll invoices that include wages or employer’s NIC? Fix or disclose before SPA.
Official anchors: HMRC’s VAT Input Tax manual, Supply and Consideration, running payroll, and employment intermediary materials where the model is actually staff supply.
Redesign patterns that survive scrutiny
A — pure payroll bureau. Vendor runs PAYE/RTI/payslips. You remain employer. Fee (+VAT) only. No reclaim on wages/NIC. Correct for most SMEs that only wanted admin relief.
B — genuine staff supply. Vendor employs, pays, and invoices a labour charge. Your contracts and control rights must match. Do not mix A facts with B invoices.
C — secondment / intra-group recharge. Document employer, host, recharge basis and VAT grouping. Grouping does not cure a mischaracterised external wrapper.
D — umbrella / labour-supply chain. Post-April 2026 joint and several liability makes chain maps mandatory. Treat labour-supply chains as employment-tax and VAT diligence. See Deloitte’s 2026 UK tax landscape.
Bottom line
Its Plant-Tech is a substance case dressed as an input-tax dispute. Outsourcing the calculator does not outsource the employment. A third-party PAYE scheme does not create a labour supply. A VAT invoice does not create a taxable supply. £569k evaporates when the Tribunal asks: what, exactly, did you buy?
Keep the bureau fee. Drop the fantasy labour supply. Lock the employer file before HMRC locks it for you.
Further reading: the judgment, Claritax’s note, VATupdate’s round-up, HMRC Notice 700, and ICAEW’s tax news stream.

Pingback: KC [2026] UKFTT 1300: Why an Unregistered Predecessor Still Cannot Manufacture a Clean VAT Start — and What Every CFO Must Lock on TOGC History, Taxable-Person Status and Acquisition Files | Tanous | PE CFO Insights by Mark Hendy